Baskin-Robbins’ New Whoopie Pie, Who Wants a Freebie

New this year to Baskin-Robbins’ and available for a limited time only… customizable Whoopie Pies.  The Whoopie Pie features a combination of chocolate cake with any Baskin-Robbins ice cream flavor sandwiched in between. You can purchase Whoopie Pie cake pieces as a take-home item to build and decorate your own.

Baskin Robbins Whoopie PieThrough October, you can customize your Whoopie Pies with the October Flavor of the Month, Trick OREO® Treat, which features vanilla ice cream with orange crème-filled OREO® cookies, Baby Ruth® and Butterfinger® candy pieces.  I’ve got a $10.00 Baskin-Robbins gift card up for grabs.  Leave a comment with your Whoopie Pie ice cream combination for a chance to win.

105 comments on “Baskin-Robbins’ New Whoopie Pie, Who Wants a Freebie

  1. Alison says:

    I’d probably stick with mint chocolate chip or something like that.

    • Julia says:

      OK. Chocolate whoopie bread buns. Lunar Cheesecake slice of ice cream on top of Orange Dreamsicle slice of ice cream. Self-hardening orange syrup-icing o. Top of the ice cream. *fwap*
      (Noise when putting the top bun on a whoopie pie with icing)

      And finally, a decorative sugar-pellet image of Frankenstein on the top of the whoopie pie bun.

      You did not give any bounds of cost for this so I went all out. One last note, for people who dislike chocolate, the bun could be food-colored black/orange instead with melted white chocolate sprinkles ghostly lining the interiorside of the whoopie pie bun.

      THAT. Would be MY whoopie.

  2. Jay Two says:

    I’d def have to go with Pralines N Cream on my whoopie!

  3. Daniel Rainey says:

    Would love to try it with jamoca ice cream.

  4. Nrmliawn says:

    Mmm Reeses peanut butter cup whoopie pie please and thanks. Those look great.

  5. Christina says:

    The chocolate cake with the chocolate peanut butter ice cream.

  6. Sarah Williams says:

    Mint chocolate chip or Jamoca Almond Fudge! Those look so yummy. I don’t like the Whoopie Pies with the synthetic cream filling, but an ice cream Whoopie Pie sounds divine!

  7. Rebecca says:

    I would get Nutty Coconut ice cream in my whoopie pie

  8. Mimi says:

    Chocolate Cake with America’s Birthday Cake

  9. Jordan says:

    Reese’s Nutrageous filled vanilla ice cream sandwiched between peanut butter cakes! YUM!

  10. Helldog says:

    They used to have a “Baseball Nut” flavor that was really good. I’d do that one if they had it.

  11. Kevin says:

    I’d like to try the Halloween Oreo ice cream.

  12. Kaylin says:

    My pie combination: a gingersnap cookie with a salted caramel ice cream filling.

  13. robert says:

    Egg nog with chocolate flavored cakes.

  14. Cory says:

    Butter pecan for sure!

  15. Mike Bretz says:

    German Chocolate Cake!!!!!

  16. Stephen Z. says:

    The Halloween combo sounds good, but take out the baby ruth and substitute reeses please!

  17. Matt says:

    I’m thinking doing cookie dough… or would that be weird to eat cookie dough from out of a cookie?!?

  18. Ann S says:

    Whoopie pie with Quarterback Crunch sounds really awesome. Or just plain old regular Chocolate Chip.

    (Oh, I think I know where I’m going to go for dessert tonight!)

  19. Page Tillman says:

    I would get it with Pralines and Cream or Trick Oreo Treat.

  20. Because_racecar says:

    I’m a chocolate fanatic so how about chocolate ice cream? 🙂


  21. snuff says:

    chocolate peanut butter

  22. Marie says:

    Butter Pecan ice cream sandwiched between the Whoopie Pie Cookies.

  23. Mike says:

    I’d have it with chocolate peanut butter ice cream.

  24. Jason M says:

    Mint chocolate chip is my favorite.

  25. Santiago C says:

    I would keep it seasonal and do pumpkin

  26. Renee says:

    I think I’d like to try a cheesecake ice cream in it, but the blueberry & strawberry flavors seem like they’d be too busy with the chocolate, so I’d probably go with the lunar cheesecake.

  27. Teressa says:

    Definitely old fashioned butter pecan! Wish they had a cinnamon flavor though =P

  28. Matt K says:

    Reese’s peanut butter ice cream.

  29. Jarred says:

    I’m picky. Either world class chocolate, icing on the cake, creole cream cheese, chocolate fudge, or black walnut ice cream. All sound like possible contenders to me, even though I’ve never even tried any of these flavors lol. But yeah, it all comes down to what flavors the closest Baskin-Robbins location has to offer. I wish they had them all. 🙁

  30. Eva says:

    I may try the trick Oreo treat. I dunno, I’m way too indecisive I won’t know until I’m at the counter

  31. Brian Miller says:

    I couldn’t mess up the texture with bits, chunks, or nuts… More chocolate would be overkill… So it ‘s gotta be good ol’ vanilla.

  32. Claire says:

    Butter pecan. Yum!

  33. Von Berry says:

    I think mint chocolate chip would be awesome.

  34. Alec says:

    Cookies & Cream would work well as a whoopie pie

  35. Todd says:

    Pralines & Cream!!!

  36. Susan Christy says:

    Jamoca Almond Fudge or PB & Chocolate would be delicious!

  37. Sam says:

    The Trick Oreo Treat sounds great!

  38. Devin says:

    Reese’s ice cream is my go to flavor in any Baskin-Robbins situation.

  39. Jennifer says:

    mint choc chip yummy!

  40. Jimmy James says:

    Jeeze I don’t know, Butterfinger or cookie dough probably. I haven’t been to Baskin-Robbins in a long while and that Trick Oreo Treat looks pretty good too.

  41. Pilar says:

    I would go with Mint Chocolate Chip. YUMMY!!!

  42. BigBelly says:

    peanut butter and chocolate in between some chocolate cakes sounds good right about now 🙂

  43. Michelle says:

    Oooh, some carmel and toffee with some pistachio icecream :9

  44. MR. Gnarly says:

    German Chocolate Cake Ice Cream….Chocolate bliss!

  45. Jay says:

    Chocolate covered strawberry

  46. Ray says:

    Pistachio ice cream.

  47. Nort says:

    poop! jk just havin some fun. vanilla

  48. Jeff says:

    Mint choc chip!

  49. Fred says:

    Nice calorie bomb there, Baskin.

  50. Ryan N says:

    I’d have to go w/ that Trick Oreo Treat. That sounds yummy!!!

  51. Tom says:

    Mint choc chip, yum!

  52. Eagles409 says:

    Pralines and cream. It sounds odd, but I think it might work.

  53. Sam says:

    Trick OREO treat for me.

  54. Kacy says:

    I think I might have to stick with their October special – sounds great!

  55. Erin says:

    Trick OREO® Treat sounds good, but might be a little too sweet. I also might go with something simple like strawberry.

  56. Tom H says:

    Creole Cream Cheese would be perfect, IMO

  57. Anne Sutton says:

    I used to love Mallomar cookies as a kid. I would have to add lots of whipped topping to the ice cream in my whoopie pie. For flavor, I would go with their world class chocolate with all the different chocolates in it. Yummy!

  58. Casey H says:

    I’d still have to go with the standard cookies n’ cream… Seriously just cant get enough of CnC.

  59. Christine says:

    Mint ‘n chip for me please! 🙂

  60. Dannielle says:

    Love to try that trick oreo treat, I’m a sucker for anything Halloween.

  61. Echo710 says:

    Does “Gold Medal Ribbon” still exist? That flavor was a childhood favorite of mine. …Otherwise I would have to go with pumpkin.

  62. Eric says:

    Instinctively, Mint Chocolate Chip. That Trick OREO® Treat might win me over though. Sounds like a tasty combo.

  63. Kyle says:

    Peanut butter chocolate.

  64. Jennfier says:

    chocolate cake with peanut butter chocolate ice cream…heck yeah!

  65. Matthew C says:

    When I was young my cousin and I invented a whoopie pie we called the WUBBA-FLABBA! I would take those whoopi pie cookies and layer in some cherry jubilee , then add a warm chocolate chip cookie, Then I would add the limited edition trick Oreo treat , then a brownie , some hot fudge , m@ms vanilla ice cream then the top whoopi pie

  66. Kate W. says:

    Either mint chocolate chip or Reese’s peanut butter cup. Or Cookies and Cream. So many good options!

  67. Curtis says:

    Mint with Cookies and Cream would make a good combo for the whoopee pie.

  68. Ryan says:

    Strawberry with strawberry cheesecake would be pretty darn tasty 🙂

  69. Lily Sheng says:

    My favorite Pistachio ice cream would probably taste amazing sandwiched in the chocolate cakes!

  70. Patrick Bateman says:

    Can’t go wrong with cookies n cream!

  71. Chris says:

    I’ll try one with cookies & cream!

  72. Ivory says:

    I’d go with the Trick Oreo Treat or with the Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup.

  73. Brent says:

    I would Whoop up a combination that involved Reese’s Cups.

  74. Karina says:

    The new Trick OREO sounds perfect for a whoopie pie! YUM!

  75. Rob says:

    Trick Oreos Treat me.

  76. Michael says:

    nutty coconut ice cream!

  77. Mary L. says:

    Gold Medal Ribbon! If only Chocolate Raspberry Truffle were still around, though… 🙁

  78. Aly says:

    German chocolate cake inside of mine!

  79. BL says:

    Reese’s PB cup ice cream in between them

  80. dean says:

    neopolitan (strawberry, vanilla, chocolate) whoopie pie.

  81. Elm99 says:

    Mint chocolate chip!

  82. Sean says:

    I might give the pictured Trick Oreo Treat option a shot. Never had that flavor and it looks decent. That, or maybe Chocolate Peanut Butter for nostalgia. Used to get that all the time after baseball games.

  83. Michael says:

    Raspberry Cheese Louise Ice Cream

  84. Sheila says:

    Yum! Any would be good, but I’d probably choose Pralines and Cream or the Trick Oreo Treat!

  85. Dani says:

    Gold medal ribbon!

  86. VanessaB says:

    Pralines and cream whoopsie pie for me!! I need one now!!

  87. Icedus says:

    …That actually sounds pretty good right there. I think I’d just point to the article on my tablet and go “GIMME TWO OF THIS.”

  88. Michael says:

    I’m going with that new trick or treat oreo ice cream, sounds delicious.

  89. Jen says:

    I’d like to try this exact combo with the treat oreo treat! It looks delish!!

  90. ROBERT P./ ROBERTO / says:


  91. Jay Melo says:

    Chocolate pie with mint chip ice cream, yummy!

  92. Katie M says:

    I’d use Strawberry ice cream inside!

  93. Raven says:

    Heath toffee crunch should be delish

  94. mattm says:

    cookies and cream

  95. Stephen K says:

    Okay, I can go for the Trick Oreo Treat. Haven’t tried it yet.

  96. Sarah says:

    Peanut Butter chocolate!

  97. Ryan says:

    Jarred is the chosen one… the contest is now closed. Thanks for the participation everyone. Expect an email Jarred and the gift card will be on its way. Another giveaway is coming soon… any Sonic fans?

  98. Carissa says:

    Chocolate with chocolate.

  99. Laura says:

    Chocolate with strawberry.

  100. Caren says:

    Chocolate with mint.

  101. Anthony says:

    chocolate with vanilla

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *